#293: Mayfair Hotel (Pomona)

Mayfair Hotel - south entrance

Added to the National Register of Historic Places on July 31, 2017

The city of Pomona was on the move in the 1910s, quite literally. Between 1900 and 1920, the city’s population more than doubled from 5,526 to 13,505, many of them drawn to the booming citrus industry. And all those Pomonans had a whole lot of new transportation options. Pomona had gained a third railroad when the Union Pacific came to town in 1904; new car garages sprung up to serve the nascent automobile industry; and the Pacific Electric interurban railway started serving Pomona in 1912.

Newcomers, tourists and businesspeople had a fine place to stay in the Mayfair Hotel, right in Pomona’s historic downtown at the corner of 3rd Street and Garey Avenue. This was conveniently located for new arrivals, just two blocks from the Southern Pacific Railroad station, and right next to the Pacific Electric route on Garey. Two major auto thoroughfares, Holt Boulevard and Mission Boulevard, were just a couple blocks north and south, respectively.

The Mayfair was built in 1915 as the Avis Hotel. That first incarnation was named after its owner, Walter Moore Avis. In addition to being appointed as Pomona’s postmaster by Teddy Roosevelt, Avis was a major builder in the area, responsible for fine houses, theaters and office blocks. He and a syndicate of developers had planned to build a hotel at the northeast corner of 3rd and Garey as early as 1911, when the famous Hotel Palomares (then known as the Pomona Tavern) burned down, just a few blocks north where The Union on Garey is today. 

Literally the day after the fire, the Pomona Daily Review reported that Avis’s team already had the architectural plans for a five-story hotel “as nearly fireproof as it can be built – concrete walls and cement floors.” The whole shebang was set to cost $75,000.

In September of 1911, the old Presbyterian church at 3rd and Garey was demolished to make room for the Avis. “Will Begin to Build Soon,” promised the Pomona Morning Times. And then…nothing. For reasons that aren’t entirely clear, it would take another two and a half years for work to begin in earnest. A ‘round-the-world trip by Mr. and Mrs. Avis in 1914 may have had something to do with the delay, and one imagines the start of WWI didn’t help. But by April of 1915, The Pomona Progress was reporting a sign sticking out of the corner of the construction site, saying “Dirt given away; help yourself!”

Mayfair Hotel - excerpt from The Pomona Progress, May 10, 1915
The Pomona Progress, May 10, 1915

That spring, Avis signed a contract with Meyer & Holler (aka the Milwaukee Building Company), one of the pre-eminent architecture firms working around Los Angeles in the early 1900s. In later years the firm would design dozens of landmark buildings, including the Chinese and Egyptian Theatres, the Hollywood Athletic Club and the E. Clem Wilson Building. Meyer & Holler were proponents of the “design-build” model, wherein a client would contract with a single entity to handle both design and construction, which often led to cost and time savings.

For the Avis Hotel, Meyer & Holler planned a mostly red brick structure in neoclassical style, with a first floor clad in white “enamel brick.” Each of the windows on the south and west facades have a concrete lintel above it with angled sides for some decorative flair, and on the same two facades, there’s a cornice projecting up above the fifth floor windows, with toothy dentils underneath. 

Mayfair Hotel, Southwest corner
Southwest corner

Of your hotel accommodations, I would prefer not to speak, except to say, thousands of dollars are kept away from Pomona in winter time by want of suitable hotel quarters. The Avis hotel may in small part remedy this.

-“A New Yorker’s Impressions of Pomona,” The Bulletin, July 20, 1915

Originally the second floor wasn’t actually a floor – it was open to allow for higher ceilings for the retail spaces on the bottom floor. The only exception was a segment of floor that used to lead guests through a trio of French doors, and onto a sun deck atop the entryway portico.

Early reports cited 57 guest rooms, most with en suite bathrooms, plus a large lobby and dining room. The Avis was equipped with elevators and steam heat, space for four storefronts on the ground floor and a basement with a boiler room, machinery room and plenty of storage. The mezzanine level contained a separate dining room and kitchen, plus a ladies parlor and reception room. 

Postcard of the Avis Hotel, date unknown (via cardcow.com)

The opening of a major hotel was big news in Pomona at the time. The local papers reported on the placement of fire escapes, the installation of boilers, the hiring of hotel manager SJ Walling, the source of the furnishings and drapes, and the businesses that leased the first floor storefronts. In separate stories in The Pomona Progress, we learned that there was no room 13 in the hotel, and that two unexpected tourists from San Francisco had somehow convinced hotel management to stay at the Avis three days before it was open to the public. Businessman Mark Potter was none too happy that he’d been robbed of the honor of being the first guest, as Walter Avis had promised.

After the cement fountain is put in about 25 bricklayers will be turned loose on the job, and the five story building will climb cloudward so rapidly that it will obstruct the milky way before the stellar dairy maid can get a new trail broken across the starry welkin.

–The Pomona Progress on the Avis Hotel, July 2, 1915 

Workmen were still putting the final touches on the plumbing, electricity and interiors on New Year’s Day, 1916, just two days before the place was set to open. Finally on the afternoon of January 3 an informal reception was held, with a speech by the Mission Inn’s owner Frank Miller, and another by Judge Charles Neely of Pomona College. Served for dinner that night was oyster cocktail, turtle soup, filet of sole with tartar sauce, roast turkey with oyster dressing, an assortment of veggies and desserts and coffee.

There’s not much in the public record about the early years of the Avis Hotel. We know that the UC Berkeley Golden Bears track team stayed there when they came to meet with the Pomona College team in 1925, and that the following year the Avis Hotel Cafe downstairs held a re-opening. But if the guest registers still exist somewhere, they haven’t yet been recovered by the current owners.

There’s also evidence that the hotel was purchased in 1918 by Ethel Bullock and her husband Joseph, who leased it out to various operators over the next decade and change. One of them was hotelier Neil H. Edgar who took over in 1927. In keeping with Walter Avis’s naming tradition, Edgar re-christened it the Edgar Hotel. The building was treated to a $35,000 glow-up, including $20,000 in all-new furniture and $15,000 in exterior brick repair and repainting of the window ledges. 

Mayfair Hotel - Edgar Hotel ad
Ad in The Bulletin, April 3, 1927

The Edgar lasted fewer than five years (I imagine the Great Depression didn’t help) before its owner Ethel Bullock opted to try her hand at hotel operations. Bullock changed the hotel name to the Mayfair, and gave it another round of renovations in the spring of 1932 just in time for the Olympics and the LA County Fair. In addition to redecorating the lobby and swapping in new mattresses, Bullock put up the “Hotel Mayfair” blade sign that you can still see today, suspended from the southwest corner of the building.

The Mayfair Hotel was a family affair during Mrs. Bullock’s reign. Her sons Hubert and Jimmy Foster helped manage the place, while their wives Kathleen and Ella took turns as receptionists, switchboard operators and restaurant hostesses. 

Mayfair Hotel - west view
West side of the building

During the 1930s, the Mayfair mostly served salesmen and tourists coming through town on their way to or from Los Angeles, plus some permanent guests who stayed in the suites on the fifth floor. This was pre-freeway, so the Mayfair’s dining room became a frequent stop for hungry drivers and bus passengers heading east or west on the nearby thoroughfares of Holt and Mission Boulevards. Diners could finally order adult beverages as of 1933, when Pomonans voted to reverse the city’s nearly half-century status as a dry town.

While the Bullocks continued to own the Mayfair Hotel throughout the ’30s and ’40s, there was a revolving door of proprietors who leased it from them. C.O. Lee and G.W. Fox signed a 10-year-lease in 1938, which was then purchased by Mr. and Mrs. W.S. Saunders from San Francisco in 1940. A year later, for reasons that remain unclear, the Bullocks bought all of the equipment and merchandise used by the Saunders family at the hotel and downstairs cocktail lounge, and resumed operations themselves.

WWII brought servicemen to the hotel, often with girlfriends, wives and family to see them off before they went to war. There’s also a confirmed story about Clark Gable’s visit to the Mayfair. According to Ethel Bullock’s daughter-in-law Ella Foster, Gable was planning to buy a horse for Carole Lombard, and stopped by for a discussion with a horse trainer who lived at the Mayfair as a permanent guest. Other unsubstantiated stories place various celebrities at the Mayfair (Lucy and Desi Arnaz come up a lot), often in connection with the Fox Theater across the street.

Mayfair Hotel - looking north on Garey Avenue
View looking north on Garey Avenue from the Mayfair Hotel rooftop, ca. 1940s (courtesy Pomona Valley Historical Society)

Ethel Bullock died in a car crash in 1951, on her way back home from breakfast with her son Hubert. Three years later her half-interest in the hotel was sold to hotelier Nieuport B. Estes, who modernized the rooms with carpeting, Venetian blinds, formica-topped desks, new baths and linoleum flooring in the bathroom. 

The 1960s witnessed one of the most eyebrow-raising episodes in the Mayfair Hotel’s history, one that made a significant contribution to legal history. It all started on October 25, 1960, when two men robbed the Budget Town Food Market in Monrovia. One of the men was holding a gun, and wore horn-rimmed glasses and a grey jacket. 

Mayfair Hotel - 1954
From the September 1, 1954 issue of the Progress-Bulletin

In the market’s parking lot, a checkbook was found in the name of a man named Joseph Lyle Stoner, and two stubs made out to the Mayfair Hotel for rent. When the police looked up Stoner in their records, they learned that he had an extensive criminal record including murder, multiple robberies and a successful escape from a Tehachapi prison, just months before he was set to be let out on parole on a life sentence. The cops showed a picture of Stoner to the witnesses at Budget Town Food Market, and they affirmed that he was the guy with the gun.

When the cops visited the Mayfair Hotel to investigate, Stoner wasn’t there, but the night clerk happily agreed to let them search his room without a warrant. There they found the gun, bullets, horn-rimmed glasses and clothes that matched the victims’ description of their assailant. Stoner was arrested two days later in Las Vegas, and convicted of first degree robbery.  

Aerial view of Pomona, 1956, with Mayfair Hotel in orange box
(courtesy of Pomona Valley Historical Society)

So here’s where the legal significance comes in. Stoner appealed his conviction, arguing that the evidence of his crime was obtained without a warrant, and therefore should have been excluded from his trial. The California Courts of Appeal denied his motion for a retrial, but he appealed again. In 1964 the Supreme Court unanimously agreed that the police had searched Stoner’s hotel room illegally, that the evidence was inadmissible, and that Stoner’s conviction had to be overturned. 

This case reaffirmed previous Supreme Court rulings that hotel guests were constitutionally protected from unlawful searches and seizures. It also held that a warrantless search could only be justified as “incident to arrest” if it was close in time and vicinity to the criminal’s arrest, which they weren’t in Stoner’s case. 

Mayfair Hotel - Rathskeller ad
1962 ad for the Mayfair Hotel’s downstairs restaurant in the Progress-Bulletin. Rathskeller would become a hub for Pomona’s gay community.

Downtown Pomona was in decline by the early 1970s. The completion of the 10 and 60 freeways (soon to be joined by the 71) meant for a lot of commercial and residential development in further-afield areas accessible by car, but much less in Pomona’s historic core. Despite some heroic efforts to bring people back downtown (Millard Sheets’s Pomona Mall seemed pretty cool), the area had a tough time attracting and sustaining businesses. The famous Fox Theater, kitty-corner from the Mayfair, shut down in 1977. 

The Mayfair Hotel was in a trough during this era, too. One resident and his friend were assaulted there in 1977 – they were approached in the lobby by two women offering sexual favors, but when they went upstairs to the guy’s room, three other men ran in, robbed them and tied them up with bedsheets. 

Mayfair Hotel - blade neon sign

Once a premiere destination for tourists, the Mayfair transitioned into a single-room occupancy model, renting rooms for $100 a week to transients and the working poor. A 1990 Los Angeles Times article called it “the only [hotel] in the area that accepts emergency housing vouchers from the county.” 

The day after Thanksgiving, 1990, an electrical fire started in the basement and spread up to the restaurant level. Firefighters got the fire under control before it could engulf the upper floors, but they still had to knock down walls, ceilings and doors in the process. All in all the fire caused some $400,000 in damage. Everyone inside evacuated safely to the nearby YMCA and First Baptist Church, but the fire displaced 30 Mayfair residents, many of whom were already homeless.

When developers Dave Armstrong and Jerry Tessier bought the Mayfair in 2002 for $450,000, it had been boarded up for more than a decade. The new owners had grand ideas – loft houses, or maybe a museum with a restaurant at the bottom. “I must have taken 50-some-odd mattresses and box springs out of it,” Armstrong told the Daily Bulletin in 2011, perhaps a remnant of the brothel that was rumored to run out of it in the late 1990s.

Outdoor courtyard, above the former sun deck

Armstrong and Tessier doled out $2 million to update the hotel’s electrical and plumbing systems, and retrofit it for seismic safety. But their ambitions were never realized. They sold it in 2006 to another developer, who spent another $2 million on converting the Mayfair into condos, then ran out of money.

That’s when John Speidel came along. Speidel was a professional developer with a long history in Pomona. Back in 1970 he built Pomona’s tallest building, a nine-story tower of bare concrete and glass at Fourth Street & Park Avenue. One day in January of 2010, Speidel was paying his utility bill at the gas company’s office across from the Mayfair, when he bumped into its former owner, Dave Armstrong. “Why don’t you buy that?” Armstrong suggested. So he did. Speidel picked up the Mayfair Hotel for $650,000 at a bankruptcy sale, less than the median price of a single-family home in Pomona today.  

Working with his son David as project manager, Speidel got a loan for $3.5 million to finish the job that previous owners hadn’t. They hired Optimum Seismic to gut the interiors and retrofit the building for earthquake safety. They reconfigured old hotel rooms into 32 apartments – studios, one and two-bedrooms. They added new stairwells, installed an elevator and sprinklers. The second floor, originally a taller extension of the first, became a closed off floor of its own to accommodate more rooms. 

On the east side of the building, the Speidels cut out a new entryway for apartment dwellers. The original entrance on 3rd Street now contains doors to two retail spaces, currently occupied by O’Donovan’s Restaurant & Pub and Wish You Were Here Coffee. 

Aside from the interior reconfiguration and a new set of solar panels, the Speidels stayed faithful to the historic character of the Mayfair. They brought on historic consultant John Clifford to research and advise on rehabbing the place according to the Secretary of the Interior’s standards. There’s exposed brick on the inside of each unit that’s been in place for over a century. They preserved and repainted the original fire escapes. Only 10 of the 188 window frames and sashes had to be replaced. The window screens themselves aren’t original, but the team fabricated replicas based on a single original one they found when they pulled off the plywood coverings on the second floor. 

Post-renovation photos taken by John Clifford on March 24, 2016

And what of the neon blade sign mounted on the corner? It was restored and switched on for the first time in a decade. And in the process of restoring it, they uncovered a surprise: a neon “Edgar” underneath the neon “Mayfair,” a relic of the five-year window from 1927-1932 when this was the Edgar Hotel. 

The Mayfair reopened in 2012 as the Mayfair Hotel Apartments, with fully-furnished rooms geared towards students at Western University of Health Sciences a few blocks east. There are plenty of non-student Pomonans who live there now, too. 

John Speidel passed away in 2015, well into his eighties. Thankfully he lived long enough to see his last major project through, and to witness local history buffs admire  the restoration job during a couple home tours organized by Pomona Heritage. His son David still manages the Mayfair. 

Mayfair Hotel - busted portico
The busted portico overhang

I spoke with David before my visit to the Mayfair Hotel in March of 2026. He told me stories of the cool stuff they uncovered during the restoration. He also mentioned that delivery trucks keep knocking into the overhang above the entry portico on 3rd Street, because it sticks out about a foot beyond the curb. The work of maintaining a historic property is never done. 


Thank you to historian John Clifford for answering my questions about the Mayfair, and to Victoria of the Historical Society of Pomona Valley for granting permission to use their photos.

Sources & Recommended Reading

All historic newspaper articles & ads were accessed via newspapers.com

+ “50 Displaced, 3 Injured by Hotel Blaze” (Los Angeles Times, November 25, 1990)

+ “$75,000 Hotel Will Be Erected Here Very Soon” (Pomona Morning Times, June 16, 1911)

+ “$90,000 Hotel Bid Received” (Progress Bulletin, September 1, 1954)

+ Allen, David: “Mayfair Hotel Rising from the Ashes” (Inland Valley Daily Bulletin, May 29, 2011)

+ Allen, David: “Pomona Landmark Mayfair Hotel Is Back from the Dead” (Inland Valley Daily Bulletin, October 30, 2012)

+ “Announcing the Re-Opening of The Avis Hotel Cafe” (AD – Pomona Bulletin, September 12, 1926)

+ “Ask to Change Fire Escapes on New Hotel Bldg.” (Pomona Daily Review, October 5, 1915)

+ “Avis Hotel to Be Completed by November 15” (Pomona Progress, April 24, 1915)

+ “Avis Hotel to be Formally Opened on January 3” (Pomona Bulletin, December 17, 1915)

+ “Avis Orders Hotel Basement Dug” (Pomona Progress, April 2, 1915)

+ “Bears Arrive Today” (Los Angeles Times, March 27, 1925)

+ Blake, Gene: “‘Fruit of the Poisonous Tree’ Wins Defendant 3rd Trial” (Los Angeles Times, February 6, 1967)

+ Blish, Tipton: “Hope for what lies beneath” (Los Angeles Times, October 10, 2002)

+ “A Brief History of the Pomona Arts Colony” (pomonaartscolony.com)

+ Clifford, John: Mayfair Hotel’s NRHP nomination form (March 28, 2016 – via nps.gov)

+ “Business Briefs Pomona: Mayfair Hotel building gets new owners” (Los Angeles TImes, July 24, 2002)

+ “Contract Signed for Erection of Beautiful Avis Hotel Building Second Structure Announced” (Pomona Daily Review, May 8, 1915)

+ “Dirt Flying for New Avis Hotel Building” (Pomona Progress, July 2, 1915)

+ “Fire Destroys Pomona Tavern” (Pomona Progress, June 14, 1911)

+ “Five Story Hotel Building to Be Started Next Month by W.M. Avis (Pomona Progress, May 10, 1915)

+ “Five-Story Hotel to Go Up on Corner Third St. and Garey Ave” (Pomona Daily Review, June 15, 1911)

+ “Frank Miller Urges Loyalty to New Hotel” (Pomona Progress, January 4, 1916)

+ Historic Resources Group: “Historic Context Statement, City of Pomona” (pomonaca.gov, September 2022)

+ History of Pomona Valley California with Biographical Sketches of The Leading Men and Women of the Valley Who Have Been Identified with Its Growth and Development from the Early Days to the Present (Historic Record Company, 1920 – via Internet Archive)

+ “Hotel Leased for 10 Years” (Progress-Bulletin, September 27, 1938)

+ “Installing Boilers Today in the New Avis Hotel Building” (Pomona Daily Review, October 15, 1915)

+ John Speidel Obituary (Inland Valley Daily Bulletin, published November 9, 2015)

+ “Lease, Not Mayfair Hotel Itself Sold, Foster Explains” (Progress-Bulletin, June 1, 1940)

+ “Locals: The former and old-time Presbyterian church…” (Pomona Daily Review, September 20, 1911)

+ Maio, Pat: “There’s a new look along Antique Row“ (Los Angeles Times, December 5, 2004)

+ “Mark Potter to Have First Room Because He Worked Up Big Issue” (Pomona Progress, December 16, 1915)

+ “Mayfair Hotel Bought by S.F. Couple” (Progress-Bulletin, April 24, 1940)

+ “Mayfair Hotel Purchase by Arizonan Confirmed” (Progress-Bulletin, September 17, 1954)

+ “Mayfair Hotel Renovation- Optimum Seismic” (@optimumseismic5368 on YouTube, August 11, 2020)

+ mayfairpomona.com

+ “Modernization Reaches Upper Hotel Floors” (Progress-Bulletin, January 19, 1955)

+ “Mrs. Bullock, Foster Again Manage Hotel” (Progress-Bulletin, October 17, 1941)

+ “Name of Hotel to Be Changed” (Progress-Bulletin, April 22, 1932)

+ “The New Edgar Hotel” (AD – Pomona Bulletin, April 3, 1927)

+ “New Hotel Man Starting Work in This City” (Pomona Bulletin, April 3, 1927)

+ “New Hotel Soon Will Be Ready for Opening” (Pomona Daily Review, November 19, 1915)

+ “Notice of Intended Sale” (Progress-Bulletin, September 11, 1941)

+ “A New Yorker’s Impressions of Pomona” (Pomona Bulletin, July 20, 1915)

+ “Official Opening of Avis Hotel Monday, Jan. 3 (Pomona Progress, December 15, 1915)

+ “Ontario Youths Confess Murder; To Face Trial” (Progress-Bulletin, November 27, 1941)

+ “Our New Postmaster” (Pomona Daily Review, December 17, 1903)

+ People v. Stoner, 205 Cal. App. 2d 108 (decided June 26, 1962 – via justia.com)

+ “Pomona Mall” (laconservancy.org) 

+ “Pomonan Buys His 3rd Hotel” (Progress Bulletin, February 28, 1929)

+ “Pomona Woman Dies in Crash in Desert” (Progress-Bulletin, November 1, 1951)

+ “Rathskeller Pomona” (AD – Progress-Bulletin, November 2, 1962)

+ “Renovation of Hostelry Done” (Pomona Progress, May 14, 1927)

+ Rodriguez, Monica: “Pomona’s Mayfair hosted movie stars in its heyday” (Inland Valley Daily Bulletin, September 15, 2002 – via NRHP form)

+ “Rule Voids Evidence in ‘Illegal Search’” (Long Beach Press-Telegram, March 23, 1964)

+ “Some Facts About Opening of New Avis Hotel Bldg.” (Pomona Bulletin, December 17, 1915)

+ “Stabler Will Move Middle of January” (Pomona Bulletin, December 21, 1915)

+ “Stoner Caught; Other Killer Still on Loose” (Progress-Bulletin, August 2, 1955)

+ Stoner v. California, 376 U.S. 483 (decided March 23, 1964 – via justia.com) 

+ “Tourists Spent Night at Avis Hotel; Owner to Breakfast at Dawn” (Pomona Progress, December 31, 1915)

+ “Valley crime: Two assaulted in hotel” (Progress-Bulletin, February 20, 1977)

+ “Walter M. Avis, 73, Prominent Pioneer Resident, Succumbs” (Progress-Bulletin, December 5, 1936)

+ Ward, Mike: “Homeless Again After Fire Guts a Homey Hotel” (Los Angeles Times, November 29, 1990)

+ “Watsonville Man will Run New Hotel” (Pomona Progress, November 20, 1915)

+ “Will a New and Finer Hotel Be Built on Ruins of the Burned Tavern” (Pomona Daily Review, June 15, 1911)

+ “Will Begin to Build Soon” (Pomona Morning Times, September 2, 1911)

+ “Work on Avis Hotel Will Be Started During the Month of May” (Pomona Progress, April 29, 1915)


Discover more from Etan Does LA

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Etan R.
  • Etan R.
  • Music omnivore, student of LA history, beer snob and amateur father. Working my way through the canon.

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.